Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Does my landlord have to provide air-conditioning?

Bit hot today.






There might be a few of you wondering whether you can make your landlord install air-conditioning.

The answer is: maybe, there's an argument for it, but it depends.

The Residential Tenancies Act 2010 does not say anything specifically about air-conditioning. (It does, however, contemplate that facilities for 'cooling' (and, for that matter, 'heating') may be 'essential services' that justify an urgent repair in the event of a breakdown).

The most relevant provisions for sweltering tenants are the contractual obligations the Act places on landlords to provide the premises 'fit for habitation' (section 52(1)) and to provide and maintain the premises 'in a reasonable state of repair, having regard to the age of, rent payable for and prospective life of the premises' (section 63(1)).

The 'fit for habitation term' and the 'reasonable state of repair term' are, apparently, two separate obligations. The Tribunal has pondered their relationship and differences here.

The fit for habitation term is the more objective: it means that the premises are safe and reasonably comfortable. This comes from the nineteenth century English case of Proudfoot v Hart (1890) 25 QBD 42, where the words 'fit for habitation' were held to mean that 'the premises might be used and dwelt in not only with safety, but with reasonable comfort, by the class of persons by whom and for the sort of purpose for which, they were to be occupied'. As the Tribunal observes, consideration of 'the class of persons' should now be dispensed with as anachronistic, and instead a generally observed, contemporary standard of safety and reasonable comfort should be applied.

The 'reasonable state of repair' term is more relative: the standard here may vary according to the rent payable for the premises, and to how much longer the premises are to remain standing. This means, in particular, that the standard of repair for relatively expensive premises may be relatively high – higher than what might be required to be merely 'fit for habitation'.

A case for air-conditioning could be made under either of these obligations, but it will depend very much on the circumstances.

For example, it's possible to think of premises – for example, a west-facing flat, with fixed windows and no insulation, somewhere that regularly gets hot – that will not be reasonably comfortable without air-conditioning, so the case might be made that air-conditioning is required for those premises by the fit for habitation term.

On the other hand, in other premises – say a $5000 per week penthouse in a luxurious new building – air-conditioning might be required under the 'reasonable state of repair' term, even if the discomfort is not so bad as to make the premises uninhabitable.

In any event, the extreme weather conditions today will be a poor test of what's required by these obligations. For today, keep a T-shirt in the fridge. If your place gets uncomfortably hot even in ordinary weather, consider asking your landlord to do something about it. 

7 comments:

  1. Air Conditioning providing accurate temperature control,
    and it reduce the humidity within your home to eliminate the 'stickiness' .
    Most systems have a dedicated 'dry' mode,
    where humidity can be reduced without over-cooling the room.



    air conditionin
    air conditioner
    ac air conditioning
    furnace
    hvac

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing the information regarding Air Conditioning.
    Heating Repair Kenosha

    ReplyDelete
  3. Air-conditioning might be required under the 'reasonable state of repair' term, even if the discomfort is not so bad as to make the premises uninhabitable. Ac service katy

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. That's interesting that a landlord might not have to provide air conditioning because the place is still habitable without it. Living without air conditioning or heating can be hard though! You have to keep your windows open in the summer and layer on the blankets in the winter. If I didn't have either in my apartment, I would talk to the landlord and see what arrangements could be made. http://www.aoneheatingandair.com/air-conditioning/

    ReplyDelete
  6. The blog is wonderful and has helped me to have wonderful ideas on how to maintain the air conditioning system. Air Conditioning Service Chandler AZ

    ReplyDelete

Please keep your comments PC - that is, polite and civilised. Comments may be removed at the discretion of the blog administrator; no correspondence will be entered into. Comments that are abusive of individual persons, or are sexist, racist or otherwise offensive will be removed, so don’t bother leaving them.